Can’t resist doing 360’s in front of the mirror? Instead of turning every which way under those unforgiving lights, try giving a look in the First Date Fashionista mirror—I can tell you which outfit is the fairest one of them all.

First up on the agenda: The disheveled co-ed (pictured, right).

Just a few points on execution and this young gent will be lightin’ up the room in style. I can tell the jeans are good quality, but they look like they sat in the dryer for about 12 hours. I know it’s a pain in the tuchus, but ironing jeans will make for a crisp, clean look. Unfortunately, women DO notice these things…

The brown lace-ups are solid, but they aren’t the best match with the black jacket. I’d suggest going for either a lighter shade of brown (camel hue) or casual to dressy black shoes.

Bottoms up! I love the black cord jacket and button-up shirt. Vertical stripes are always flattering, and the hint of color is just enough to make the blazer pop. I do have an issue with the gray undershirt in this combination—stick to white or black. Also, if you don’t mind flaunting a little skin, nix the tee altogether and leave the top button open. You won’t look too uptight if you button it all the way up. (A word of caution: If you have one of those hirsute, super fuzzy chests, it’s probably best to cover up unless you want to submit yourself to a Steve Carrel-esque waxing experience. Sorry guys.)

He’s got the right idea, but could smarten up a bit. We give disheveled co-ed a B.